Editing and contributions from offline users
Fragment of a discussion from Talk:Task force/Offline
Generically speaking, the concept is good but has substantial technological challenges depending on the scenario:
- Non-internet-accessible school site, long period synchronization
- Scenario: Synchronizes local dump at start of school year.
- Multiple classes of students with editing integrated in the curriculum over the course of the school year.
- End of school year synchronization of thousands of student edits to revisions now 9 months out of date
- High number of edit conflicts predictable
- Single synchronizer (school teacher?) becomes responsible for resolving each edit conflict for entire school even though xe may not have relevant knowledge.
- Single-user short period synchronization
- Scenario: cellphone synchronizes weekly automated.
- Edit conflicts, after hand resolve, are then delayed until the next week's updating, at which point they may have developed another edit conflict.
- Scenario: cellphone synchronizes weekly automated.
- Any remote scenario
- en.WP admins/CVN see a blast of edits from a given user/IP, especially if poorly formatted, and their likely response is to block/rollback all contributions.
- Most such synchronizations would be effectively indistinguishable from bot edits, and may be in violation of some project's bot/automated edits policies
Some of these may be resolved via technological measures, such as a more contextual edit resolver, but it is unlikely they could be 100% resolved. I would question whether - at this stage - this should be a primary recommendation.